
Bankerology Editorial Team
Nov 19, 2026
Moving but hate to give up a 3% mortgage? Compare renting your home out with selling, including cash flow, the 3-year tax window and financing.
Updated November 19, 2026.
A new job, a growing family or a move closer to relatives does not care what your mortgage rate is. But if you locked in around 3% in 2020 or 2021, selling means giving that rate up and borrowing again at about 7.11% (Freddie Mac, November 12, 2026). That is why many movers now ask a different question: what if I keep the house, rent it out, and buy the next one?
It can be a smart move or an expensive headache. Here is how to decide.
A low fixed rate keeps your largest cost flat for decades. On a $250,000 balance at 3% with 24 years left, principal and interest is about $1,219 a month. A new buyer financing the same amount today at 7.11% over 30 years would pay about $1,682. That gap is what makes your home easier to rent profitably than most homes bought recently.
Rent has to cover more than the mortgage. Add up every cost, using your own numbers:
| Monthly item | Illustration | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Expected rent | $2,600 | Check local listings for similar homes |
| Mortgage principal and interest | -$1,219 | Your fixed payment |
| Property taxes | -$400 | From your escrow statement |
| Landlord insurance | -$175 | A landlord policy replaces your homeowners policy |
| Repairs and maintenance reserve | -$300 | Set aside every month, even in quiet months |
| Vacancy reserve | -$150 | Covers gaps between tenants |
| Property management | -$260 | If you will live far away |
| Monthly cash flow | +$96 | Before income tax |
Illustration only, with assumed figures. Replace every line with your own numbers.
In this example the house roughly pays for itself, while the tenant pays down about $600 a month of principal on a 3% loan and you keep any appreciation. If your numbers come out negative, you are paying to be a landlord, and selling may be the better choice.
When you sell a home you have lived in for at least two of the last five years, you can exclude up to $250,000 of profit from tax, or $500,000 for married couples filing jointly. Once you move out and rent the home, that clock keeps running. In practice, you have about three years after moving out to sell and still claim the full exclusion.
If you rent it longer than that, the entire gain becomes taxable when you sell. Two more tax rules to know:
A tax professional can map your exact timeline. The key decision is whether you are renting for a few years to keep your options open, or keeping the house as a long-term investment.
The hardest part of keeping your house is usually the down payment on the next one, since you are not getting sale proceeds. Your options:
Most mortgages require you to live in the home for at least a year after closing. After that, renting it out is usually allowed, but read your loan documents and switch to a landlord insurance policy before a tenant moves in.
Only if it is an FHA, VA or USDA loan. See our guide to assumable mortgages, which can make your home more attractive to buyers.
Usually not while CDs and savings accounts pay more after tax. Run the numbers with our pay off my mortgage or buy CDs calculator.
Sources: Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey (Nov 12, 2026); IRS rules on the home sale exclusion (Section 121) and residential rental depreciation (Publication 527). Bankerology is not a tax advisor; talk to a tax professional about your situation.


