Home
Mortgage
Advertiser Disclosure

Cash-Out Refinance vs. Home Equity Loan vs. HELOC: Which Costs Less?

Three ways to turn home equity into cash, compared with real 2026 numbers. If your current mortgage rate is low, a cash-out refi can cost hundreds more a month.

Updated November 17, 2026.

There are three main ways to pull cash out of your home: a cash-out refinance, a home equity loan and a HELOC. The right choice depends mostly on one number, the rate on your current mortgage. If it is well below today's rates, keep it and borrow with a second loan. If it is at or above today's rates, a cash-out refinance can make sense.

The three options in plain English

  • Cash-out refinance: you replace your entire mortgage with a new, bigger one and take the difference in cash. One loan, one payment, but your whole balance moves to today's rate.
  • Home equity loan: you keep your mortgage and add a second, fixed-rate loan paid out as a lump sum.
  • HELOC: you keep your mortgage and add a variable-rate line of credit you draw from as needed.

Side-by-side comparison

Cash-out refiHome equity loanHELOC
Average rate (Nov 2026)7.58% (30-year)8.77% (10-year)7.49% (variable)
Keeps your current mortgageNoYesYes
Typical closing costs2% to 6% of the full new loan2% to 5% of the amount borrowedLow; sometimes waived
PaymentOne fixed paymentTwo fixed paymentsMortgage plus a variable payment
Usually best whenYour current rate is at or above today'sYou need a set amount and have a low first rateYou need flexible access over time

Rates: Zillow 30-year refinance average (Nov 15, 2026); Bankrate home equity loan (Nov 11, 2026) and HELOC (Nov 4, 2026) surveys.

A real example: $50,000 in cash

Say you owe $200,000 on a mortgage at 3.5% with 25 years left. Your payment is about $1,001 a month. You want $50,000 for a renovation.

OptionNew monthly paymentChange from today
Cash-out refi: $250,000 at 7.58%, 30 years$1,762+$761
Keep mortgage + $50,000 home equity loan at 8.76%, 15 years$1,501+$500
Keep mortgage + $50,000 HELOC at 7.49%, interest only$1,313+$312 (rises later)

Principal and interest only. Bankerology calculations using the averages above.

The cash-out refinance costs about $260 a month more than the home equity loan, because it moves the original $200,000 from 3.5% to 7.58%. That is the trap: you are not just paying today's rate on the $50,000, you are paying it on everything.

When a cash-out refinance does make sense

  • Your current rate is close to or above today's rates. If you bought or refinanced in 2023 or later at 7.5% or more, a cash-out refi may lower your rate and give you cash at the same time.
  • You need a large amount. First-mortgage rates are lower than second-lien rates, so on very large amounts the spread can favor a refinance.
  • You want a single payment and are comfortable resetting the clock on your loan.

Not sure if refinancing pencils out? Run the break-even math in Should You Refinance Your Mortgage?

When a home equity loan or HELOC is the better move

  • Your first mortgage rate is meaningfully below today's rates (true for most homeowners who bought or refinanced before 2022).
  • You need less than about a quarter of your home's value.
  • You want to avoid paying closing costs on your entire mortgage balance.

This is why second liens accounted for more than half of all equity withdrawals in early 2026, according to ICE. Homeowners are choosing to protect their low first-mortgage rates.

Tax treatment is the same for all three

Interest on cash taken out is deductible only if you itemize and use the money to buy, build or substantially improve the home that secures the loan, up to the $750,000 mortgage debt limit made permanent by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. Cash used for anything else, such as paying off credit cards, does not qualify.

Frequently asked questions

How much can I take out with a cash-out refinance?

Conventional cash-out refinances generally cap the new loan at 80% of the home's value. VA cash-out loans can go higher for eligible borrowers.

Which option closes fastest?

HELOCs and home equity loans often close in two to four weeks. Cash-out refinances usually take 30 to 45 days.

Is a HELOC cheaper than a cash-out refinance?

Usually, if your existing mortgage rate is low. Just remember the HELOC rate can rise, and the payment increases once the draw period ends.

Related guides

Sources: Zillow refinance averages (Nov 15, 2026); Bankrate home equity loan survey (Nov 11, 2026); Bankrate HELOC survey (Nov 4, 2026); ICE Mortgage Monitor (June 2026). Payment figures are Bankerology calculations. Bankerology is not a lender or tax advisor.